fix(player): stop handing ExoPlayer the demuxer's buffer budget on Auto

On Auto, Dart derives a buffer size for mpv's demuxer from the device heap and
sets it as `demuxer-max-bytes`. The Android player forwarded that same number to
`DefaultLoadControl.setTargetBufferBytes`, so ExoPlayer's sample allocator was
sized by a tier table written for a different consumer: 64MB on any device whose
large heap is 512MB or less, which every Shield is.

`targetBufferBytes` is a byte cap, so the media it represents collapses as
bitrate rises — 64MB is 53s of a 10 Mbit/s stream but 5.2s of a 103 Mbit/s UHD
remux. With `prioritizeTimeOverSizeThresholds` false the cap is hard:
`shouldContinueLoading` returns false the moment the allocator reaches it no
matter how little media that is, and `shouldStartPlayback` reports READY off the
same byte term. Read-ahead that short starves the audio sink in bursts, and on a
passthrough route that is enough to keep the AudioTrack from ever starting — the
track initializes, accepts one access unit and never renders a frame. Because an
enabled audio renderer owns the MediaClock, the whole player freezes and the
black-screen watchdog then blames the video decoder and drops the session to
mpv.

Size the LoadControl target natively instead, from what actually bounds
`DefaultAllocator`: the Java heap. `min(media3's own default for a video+audio
selection, largeMemoryClass/4, availMem/4)` with a 32MB floor, the lowest tier
that has already shipped. The quarter matches the threshold the Buffer Size
setting already warns at, and the media3 default is a ceiling — this is not
"buffer more than upstream", it is "stop buffering less". Deliberately not
bitrate-aware, because the LoadControl is built during initialize, before any
media is opened. `bufferSizeAuto` carries the distinction over the channel;
`bufferSizeBytes` still travels with it because the plugin's mpv fallback
replays it as a real demuxer property, and an explicit Buffer Size choice is
still honoured verbatim.

Confirmed against the hardware in the 2.9.1 passthrough report. That reporter's
own log is a natural A/B: three runs at 64MB fail with `0 frames rendered after
8002ms`, spanning both DV conversion modes and both tunneling states, while the
single run after he manually selected 128MB logs `Position advancing` and
renders. Reproduced on the same Shield model with codec and bitrate held fixed
and only the cap varied — 6s of audio demand stalls at 64MiB and plays at
128MiB, 4 of 4 predictions, with read-ahead measured off an injected
DefaultAllocator at 65 664 and 131 776 KiB. That device reports
`dalvik.vm.heapsize` 512m, so the heap term binds first at every free-memory
level in his log and Auto now derives exactly the 128MB he had to pick by hand;
the shipped path logs `Buffer: 128MB limit (auto, heap=512MB, available=568MB)`
where it previously logged 64MB.
This commit is contained in:
edde746
2026-08-01 06:59:21 +02:00
parent 3f49bcabf8
commit 395798f28e
7 changed files with 266 additions and 12 deletions
@@ -523,6 +523,7 @@ class ExoPlayerCore(private val activity: Activity) :
fun initialize(
bufferSizeBytes: Int? = null,
bufferSizeAuto: Boolean = false,
tunnelingEnabled: Boolean = true,
audioPassthroughEnabled: Boolean = false
): Boolean {
@@ -731,23 +732,20 @@ class ExoPlayerCore(private val activity: Activity) :
.toTypedArray()
}
// Compute memory-aware buffer limits to prevent CCodec OOM crashes
// Buffer budget. `bufferSizeBytes` carries the user's explicit Buffer Size choice; on
// Auto it still arrives (Dart derives it for mpv's demuxer, which shares the property)
// but `bufferSizeAuto` says to ignore it here, because mpv's demuxer and ExoPlayer's
// sample allocator have different shapes and different failure modes.
val activityManager = activity.getSystemService(Context.ACTIVITY_SERVICE) as ActivityManager
val memoryInfo = ActivityManager.MemoryInfo()
activityManager.getMemoryInfo(memoryInfo)
val availableMB = memoryInfo.availMem / (1024 * 1024)
val availableMB = (memoryInfo.availMem / (1024 * 1024)).toInt()
val largeHeapMB = activityManager.largeMemoryClass
val targetBufferBytes = if (bufferSizeBytes != null && bufferSizeBytes > 0) {
val targetBufferBytes = if (!bufferSizeAuto && bufferSizeBytes != null && bufferSizeBytes > 0) {
bufferSizeBytes
} else {
// Scale buffer to available memory to reduce hardware decoder pressure.
// Larger buffers reduce oscillation frequency at high bitrates (50-100Mbps).
when {
availableMB <= 512 -> 30 * 1024 * 1024
availableMB <= 1024 -> 80 * 1024 * 1024
availableMB <= 2048 -> 120 * 1024 * 1024
else -> 200 * 1024 * 1024
}
LoadControlPolicy.autoTargetBufferBytes(largeHeapMB, availableMB)
}
val loadControl = DefaultLoadControl.Builder().apply {
@@ -759,7 +757,12 @@ class ExoPlayerCore(private val activity: Activity) :
setBufferDurationsMs(30_000, 60_000, 1_000, 5_000)
}
}.build()
emitLog("info", "init", "Buffer: ${targetBufferBytes / 1024 / 1024}MB limit, available=${availableMB}MB, tunneling=$tunnelingUserEnabled, dataSource=$dataSourceLabel")
emitLog(
"info",
"init",
"Buffer: ${targetBufferBytes / 1024 / 1024}MB limit (${if (bufferSizeAuto) "auto" else "manual"}, " +
"heap=${largeHeapMB}MB, available=${availableMB}MB), tunneling=$tunnelingUserEnabled, dataSource=$dataSourceLabel"
)
exoPlayer = ExoPlayer.Builder(activity)
.setTrackSelector(trackSelector!!)
@@ -285,6 +285,10 @@ class ExoPlayerPlugin :
}
val bufferSizeBytes = call.argument<Int>("bufferSizeBytes")
// Auto sizing is decided natively (LoadControlPolicy). `bufferSizeBytes` still arrives
// on Auto because Dart derives one for mpv's demuxer, which shares the property, and
// the fallback replay below needs it.
val bufferSizeAuto = call.argument<Boolean>("bufferSizeAuto") ?: false
val tunnelingEnabled = call.argument<Boolean>("tunnelingEnabled") ?: true
val dvConversionMode = call.argument<String>("dvConversionMode") ?: "auto"
val audioPassthroughEnabled = call.argument<Boolean>("audioPassthroughEnabled") ?: false
@@ -323,6 +327,7 @@ class ExoPlayerPlugin :
playerCore = core
val success = core.initialize(
bufferSizeBytes = bufferSizeBytes,
bufferSizeAuto = bufferSizeAuto,
tunnelingEnabled = tunnelingEnabled,
audioPassthroughEnabled = audioPassthroughEnabled
)
@@ -0,0 +1,60 @@
package com.edde746.plezy.exoplayer
/**
* Auto sizing for [androidx.media3.exoplayer.DefaultLoadControl]'s `targetBufferBytes` (#1618).
*
* A byte cap collapses as bitrate rises: 64 MiB is 53s of a 10 Mbit/s stream but 5.2s of a
* 103 Mbit/s UHD remux. With `prioritizeTimeOverSizeThresholds = false` the cap is hard, so
* read-ahead that short starves the audio sink in bursts — enough, on some routes, to keep a
* passthrough AudioTrack from ever starting.
*
* The tiers this replaced came from mpv demuxer OOM tuning and handed ExoPlayer a flat
* 64 MiB, under half of what media3 would pick for the same selection
* ([MEDIA3_DEFAULT_TARGET_BYTES]). The fix is not "buffer more than upstream", it is "stop
* buffering less unless the heap requires it".
*
* Not bitrate-aware: the `LoadControl` is built during `initialize`, before any media is
* opened, so a byte budget is all that is knowable.
*/
internal object LoadControlPolicy {
private const val MIB = 1024 * 1024
/**
* media3's own `calculateTargetBufferBytes` for a video + audio selection: 2000 + 200
* segments at `C.DEFAULT_BUFFER_SEGMENT_SIZE` (64 KiB). A ceiling, never exceeded here.
*/
const val MEDIA3_DEFAULT_TARGET_BYTES = 2200 * 64 * 1024
/**
* Floor, kept at the lowest tier that has already shipped, and it wins over the budgets
* below — going under it reintroduces the starvation this policy exists to prevent.
*/
const val MIN_TARGET_BYTES = 32 * MIB
/**
* Fraction of a memory budget the allocator may claim. Matches the threshold the Buffer
* Size setting already warns at (`value > heapMB / 4`).
*/
private const val BUDGET_DIVISOR = 4
/**
* @param largeHeapMB `ActivityManager.largeMemoryClass` — the hard Java-heap ceiling for
* this process, which is what bounds `DefaultAllocator` (it hands out `byte[]`).
* Non-positive when unknown.
* @param availableMB `ActivityManager.MemoryInfo.availMem`, so a device that is currently
* under pressure does not get sized purely off its theoretical heap. Non-positive when
* unknown.
*/
fun autoTargetBufferBytes(largeHeapMB: Int, availableMB: Int): Int {
var budget = MEDIA3_DEFAULT_TARGET_BYTES.toLong()
if (largeHeapMB > 0) budget = minOf(budget, largeHeapMB.toLong() / BUDGET_DIVISOR * MIB)
if (availableMB > 0) budget = minOf(budget, availableMB.toLong() / BUDGET_DIVISOR * MIB)
return maxOf(budget, MIN_TARGET_BYTES.toLong()).toInt()
}
/** Seconds of media a budget covers at [bitrateBps], for logs. Null when unknown. */
fun readAheadSeconds(targetBufferBytes: Int, bitrateBps: Long): Double? {
if (bitrateBps <= 0L) return null
return targetBufferBytes * 8.0 / bitrateBps
}
}
@@ -0,0 +1,87 @@
package com.edde746.plezy.exoplayer
import org.junit.Assert.assertEquals
import org.junit.Assert.assertNull
import org.junit.Test
private const val MIB = 1024 * 1024
class LoadControlPolicyTest {
// autoTargetBufferBytes
@Test
fun neverExceedsMedia3sOwnTargetEvenWithHugeMemory() {
assertEquals(
LoadControlPolicy.MEDIA3_DEFAULT_TARGET_BYTES,
LoadControlPolicy.autoTargetBufferBytes(largeHeapMB = 4096, availableMB = 8192)
)
}
@Test
fun heapBoundsTheTargetOnAShieldClassDevice() {
// The actual #1618 defect: the shipped tiers handed this device a flat 64MB, under half
// of media3's own choice. largeMemoryClass 512MB, ~1GB free, so the heap binds at
// 512/4 = 128MB — exactly what the reporter had to select by hand.
assertEquals(
128 * MIB,
LoadControlPolicy.autoTargetBufferBytes(largeHeapMB = 512, availableMB = 990)
)
}
@Test
fun freeMemoryBoundsTheTargetWhenItIsTighterThanTheHeap() {
assertEquals(
64 * MIB,
LoadControlPolicy.autoTargetBufferBytes(largeHeapMB = 512, availableMB = 256)
)
}
@Test
fun floorWinsOverBothBudgetsSoReadAheadCannotCollapse() {
// Going under the floor is what starves the sink on high-bitrate content; the
// allocator only grows into the target when the content is dense enough to need it.
assertEquals(
LoadControlPolicy.MIN_TARGET_BYTES,
LoadControlPolicy.autoTargetBufferBytes(largeHeapMB = 64, availableMB = 48)
)
}
@Test
fun unknownMemoryFallsBackToMedia3sTarget() {
assertEquals(
LoadControlPolicy.MEDIA3_DEFAULT_TARGET_BYTES,
LoadControlPolicy.autoTargetBufferBytes(largeHeapMB = 0, availableMB = 0)
)
}
@Test
fun unknownHeapStillRespectsFreeMemory() {
assertEquals(
64 * MIB,
LoadControlPolicy.autoTargetBufferBytes(largeHeapMB = -1, availableMB = 256)
)
}
// readAheadSeconds
@Test
fun readAheadReportsSecondsAtAKnownBitrate() {
// 64MiB of the #1618 stream (103_341 kbps) is ~5.2s — under the 15s minBufferMs, so the
// byte cap, not the time threshold, is what stops the loader.
val seconds = LoadControlPolicy.readAheadSeconds(64 * MIB, 103_341_000L)!!
assertEquals(5.19, seconds, 0.01)
}
@Test
fun readAheadDoublesWithTheTarget() {
val seconds = LoadControlPolicy.readAheadSeconds(128 * MIB, 103_341_000L)!!
assertEquals(10.39, seconds, 0.01)
}
@Test
fun readAheadIsUnknownWithoutABitrate() {
assertNull(LoadControlPolicy.readAheadSeconds(64 * MIB, 0L))
assertNull(LoadControlPolicy.readAheadSeconds(64 * MIB, -1L))
}
}
@@ -12,6 +12,7 @@ class PlayerAndroid extends PlayerBase {
static const _eventChannel = EventChannel('com.plezy/exo_player/events');
int? _bufferSizeBytes;
bool _bufferSizeIsAuto = false;
bool _tunnelingEnabled = true;
String _dvConversionMode = 'auto';
bool _audioNormalizationEnabled = false;
@@ -100,6 +101,7 @@ class PlayerAndroid extends PlayerBase {
try {
final result = await invoke<bool>('initialize', {
'bufferSizeBytes': _bufferSizeBytes,
'bufferSizeAuto': _bufferSizeIsAuto,
'tunnelingEnabled': _tunnelingEnabled,
'dvConversionMode': _dvConversionMode,
'audioPassthroughEnabled': _audioPassthroughEnabled,
@@ -287,6 +289,12 @@ class PlayerAndroid extends PlayerBase {
case 'demuxer-max-bytes':
_bufferSizeBytes = int.tryParse(value);
break;
// Not an mpv property. The heap tiers Dart derives for mpv's demuxer are the wrong
// shape for ExoPlayer's sample allocator, so on Auto the native side sizes its own
// LoadControl target instead of reusing `demuxer-max-bytes` (#1618).
case 'demuxer-max-bytes-auto':
_bufferSizeIsAuto = value != 'no';
break;
case 'tunneled-playback':
_tunnelingEnabled = value != 'no';
break;
+5
View File
@@ -1135,6 +1135,11 @@ class VideoPlayerScreenState extends State<VideoPlayerScreen> with WidgetsBindin
}
await currentPlayer.setProperty('demuxer-max-bytes', '${autoForwardMB * 1024 * 1024}');
await currentPlayer.setProperty('demuxer-max-back-bytes', '${autoBackMB * 1024 * 1024}');
// These tiers size mpv's demuxer. ExoPlayer's LoadControl allocator is a
// different consumer — a flat byte cap there collapses to a few seconds of
// read-ahead on a 100 Mbps remux — so let the native side derive its own
// target on Auto (#1618).
await currentPlayer.setProperty('demuxer-max-bytes-auto', 'yes');
} else {
// Manual mode: cap back-buffer relative to heap if 1/4 ratio is too high
final maxBackBytes = min(bufferSizeMB * 1024 * 1024 ~/ 4, autoBackMB * 1024 * 1024);
@@ -0,0 +1,86 @@
import 'package:flutter/services.dart';
import 'package:flutter_test/flutter_test.dart';
import 'package:plezy/mpv/player/platform/player_android.dart';
import 'package:plezy/services/settings_service.dart';
import '../test_helpers/mock_player_channels.dart';
import '../test_helpers/prefs.dart';
/// Drives the Buffer Size contract between Dart and `ExoPlayerPlugin` (#1618).
///
/// Auto still sends `demuxer-max-bytes`, because mpv's demuxer shares the property and the
/// plugin's mpv fallback replays it. Only `bufferSizeAuto` tells the native side that the
/// value was derived for the demuxer and that `LoadControlPolicy` should size ExoPlayer's
/// allocator instead. Getting that flag wrong is silent: playback still works, just with the
/// 64MB cap that starves a high-bitrate passthrough track.
Future<MethodCall> _captureInitialize({required Future<void> Function(PlayerAndroid player) configure}) async {
late MethodCall initialize;
await withMockPlayerChannels(
methodChannelName: 'com.plezy/exo_player',
eventChannelName: 'com.plezy/exo_player/events',
methodHandler: (call) async {
if (call.method == 'initialize') initialize = call;
return call.method == 'initialize' ? true : null;
},
testBody: () async {
final player = PlayerAndroid();
try {
await configure(player);
// requestAudioFocus is what actually triggers native initialize; the screen relies
// on that ordering so every setProperty above is cached first.
await player.requestAudioFocus();
} finally {
await player.dispose();
}
},
);
return initialize;
}
void main() {
TestWidgetsFlutterBinding.ensureInitialized();
setUp(() async {
resetSharedPreferencesForTest();
SettingsService.resetForTesting();
await SettingsService.getInstance();
});
test('Auto tells the native side to size its own LoadControl target', () async {
final initialize = await _captureInitialize(
configure: (player) async {
// What video_player_screen sends on Auto for a 512MB-heap device.
await player.setProperty('demuxer-max-bytes', '${64 * 1024 * 1024}');
await player.setProperty('demuxer-max-bytes-auto', 'yes');
},
);
final args = initialize.arguments as Map<Object?, Object?>;
expect(args['bufferSizeAuto'], isTrue);
// Still forwarded: the plugin's mpv fallback replays it as a real demuxer property.
expect(args['bufferSizeBytes'], 64 * 1024 * 1024);
});
test('an explicit Buffer Size choice is never overridden by Auto sizing', () async {
final initialize = await _captureInitialize(
configure: (player) async {
await player.setProperty('demuxer-max-bytes', '${128 * 1024 * 1024}');
},
);
final args = initialize.arguments as Map<Object?, Object?>;
expect(args['bufferSizeAuto'], isFalse);
expect(args['bufferSizeBytes'], 128 * 1024 * 1024);
});
test('an unknown heap leaves no byte cap, so the native side still picks Auto', () async {
// video_player_screen skips the whole tier block when getHeapSize() fails, so neither
// property is ever set. bufferSizeBytes must stay null rather than defaulting to a
// number the native side would treat as a deliberate choice.
final initialize = await _captureInitialize(configure: (_) async {});
final args = initialize.arguments as Map<Object?, Object?>;
expect(args['bufferSizeAuto'], isFalse);
expect(args['bufferSizeBytes'], isNull);
});
}